Golfer Login | Register

What You Need To Know: Mayville Golf Course

What You Need To Know: Mayville Golf Course

By Brian Weis

An Insightful Interview With Randy Hurst, Owner

Whether you have played a course 20+ times a year or looking to play the course for the first time, insights from an insider can help enhance your golf experience. Below is an interview with Randy Hurst who shares some valuable tidbits about the course, memorable holes and must eats and treats at the 19th.

Give Our Readers An Overview of the Golf Course/Property

Established in the early 1930s, the Mayville Golf Course ranks up there as one of the oldest, most challenging public golf courses Wisconsin has to offer! With an 18-hole golf course full of rolling hills and slopes, our greens have built a reputation as "true and smooth," and some of the best you can putt on. Conveniently located in Dodge County along the Rock River among the beautiful rolling hills of the countryside, and with excellent views, amenities and a professional staff, the Mayville Golf Course is a one-stop shop for everyone.

If Someone Was Looking To Golf In The Area, Why Should They Play Your Course?

At The Mayville Golf Course, we offer excellent customer service from our golf to bar restaurant. This hidden gem will challenge you as a golfer as well as reward you for proper placements on your approach shots into the greens. When you get to hole 14 you are done playing par 4's, the unique par 3-5-3-3-5 finish will test your skill with our small undulated greens. After your golf round come inside and visit our newly renovated bar and restaurant for one of our 40+ different beers and a panini, special blend burger, or steak fresh cut daily at Leroy Meats.

What Tips or Local Knowledge Would You Provide To Help Them Score Better At Your Course?

Proper placement off the tee is very important with how small the greens are. Most greens at The Mayville Golf Course are small and elevated with a lot of undulation. It is important to know where the pin is on the green before hitting your tee shot. When you are hitting approach shots into the greens if you miss the green you are going to want to miss in the front of the greens. If you get off the greens to the left or right, it may be difficult to go up and down.

Any recent changes to the golf course? Or any upcoming changes?

The course was purchased from the city of Mayville in 2020 by Leroy Meats. The purchase came with no golf carts, limited golf course equipment, no kitchen, out of date flooring and wallcoverings, just to name a few things. The large investment was put into the restaurant by knocking down some walls, redoing the bar layout, building a restaurant kitchen, installing a 16 tap system in the bar, and putting in a beautiful stone fireplace were some necessary steps to having an onsite restaurant called The Meating Place. The purchase of multiple pieces of greens and ground equipment, a full fleet of new carts with GPS, and removal of over 100 dead trees, improved the quality of the golf course second to none. Some renovations of bunkers, new chemical application schedule to kill weeds and dandelions, proper maintenance, and replanting of new trees helped the course to make it one the best golf courses in Dodge County.

Recent Awards or What You Are Most Proud About The Course?

We are very proud of some of the changes that were made at The Mayville Golf Course and The Meating Place Restaurant since 2020. Our team will be looking into entering in the GCOW awards and get more involved with the WSGA in the future. As far as the golf course itself we are very happy with the conditions and playability that we improved on. The proper maintenance and equipment purchased helped get the Mayville Golf Course looking beautiful again like it did in the late 90s.

What Is The Signature, Most Talked About, or Most Photographed Hole?

The Signature hole at The Mayville Golf is the par 3 hole 4. This is a downhill par 3 surrounded by water with a boulder lined creek running through the fairway before the green. It is a picturesque hole with a yardage of 128 from the back tees and plays about 10 yards shorter than the distance.

What Is Your Favorite Hole? Any Tips to Play It?

My favorite hole is the par 4 hole 11 because I feel like it is the hardest hole to par on the golf course. Playing at 413 yards from the back tees, you need to hit a tee shot in the fairway to have a look at the green on your second shot. The tree short left of the green that hangs partly in the fairway makes for a hit and hope on some approach shots to the green. The treacherous greenside bunker to the right of the green could cause some bogeys or doubles if you end up in it as well as the two-tiered green makes for some interesting putts. The best play off the tee is the right side of the fairway next to the two mounds. On your second shot landing your ball short and rolling it up on the green is the proper play to prevent hitting the tree short left of the green. Make the putt and you will be in for a birdie.

Must Have Dish or Drink after the round at the 19th Hole?

The 19th hole at The Mayville Golf Course is called The Meating Place. If beer is on you mind at the after your round then you must select one of our 16 tap beers that are rotated daily. Our signature drink would be our hand muddled old fashions. We offer an old fashion menu with over 8 different old fashioned with the best seller being the Brown Sugar Bourbon Old Fashioned. As far as The Meating Place Restaurant located in The Mayville Golf Course, you must have the Smokehouse BBQ Brisket Panini if you are eating before 4pm. At 4pm we start server our entrees and our fresh hand cut Ribeye's with the garlic butter are to die for. Make sure to start out with our famous Pork Belly Bites and Hand Breaded Mushrooms for an appetizer.

For the traveling golfer, do you have lodging onsite or partner with any area hotels?

There are multiple Airbnb's located in Mayville as well as two hotels. The Mayville Inn is a colonial style hotel located on the west side of Mayville and The Audubon Hotel Established in 1896, is an iconic staple piece settled in downtown Mayville.

Who Holds Course Record and What Was Their Score?

Stu Strook currently holds the course record with a 64 . Stu has been the golf coach at Mayville High School for almost 30 years and also runs our 8-week youth golf program in the summer. A 29 was recorded on the original 9 by Vern Schellpfeffer in 1952.

Back Tee Stats
Par: 71
Yardage: 6188
Slope: 119
Rating: 69.5

More Information
Mayville Golf Course 325 S German st. Mayville , Wisconsin, 53050 920-387-2999

More Information »

Revised: 12/20/2022 - Article Viewed 2,028 Times - View Course Profile

About: Brian Weis

Brian Weis Brian Weis is the Publisher of, a network of golf travel and directory sites including,,,, etc. Professionally, Brian is a member of the Golf Writers Association of America (GWAA), International Network of Golf (ING), Golf Travel Writers of America (GTWA), International Golf Travel Writers Association (IGTWA) and The Society of Hickory Golfers (SoHG). In 2016, Brian won The Shaheen Cup, an award given to a golf travel writer by his peers.

All of his life, Brian has been around the game of golf. As a youngster, Brian competed at all levels in junior and high school golf. Brian had a zero chance for a college golf scholarship, so he worked on the grounds crew at West Bend Country Club to pay for his University of Wisconsin education. In his adult years, his passion for the game collided with his entrepreneurial spirit and in 2004 launched In 2007, the idea for a network of local golf directory sites formed and was born. Today, the network consists of a site in all 50 states supported by national sites like, and It is an understatement to say, Brian is passionate about promoting golf and golf travel on a local, regional, national and international level.

On the golf course, Brian is known as a fierce weekend warrior that fluctuates between a 5-9 handicap. With a soft fade, known as "The Weis Slice", and booming 300+ drives, he can blast it out of bounds with the best of them.

Follow Brian Weis:

linkedin  twitter  facebook  blog  youtube  vimeo  insyagram

Contact Brian Weis: - Publisher and Golf Traveler

Share Post

Get Social

facebook   twitter   pinterest   youtube   RSS  

Free Newsletter